Roth vs Traditional IRA
Schedule C-2018Tax year 2018, closed

2018 IRA contribution limits: $5,500 under 50, $6,500 with catch-up

2018 was the first year the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act (TCJA, December 2017) was in force. The IRA contribution limits did not change from 2013 through 2018, but the brackets did. With the 12% rate replacing the old 15% rate and the 22% rate replacing the old 25% rate, Roth contributions became structurally more attractive for everyone in the new lower brackets. This page documents the 2018 numbers, the phase-outs, what changed from 2017, and what it means in hindsight.

§ I

2018 limits at a glance

Under 50

$5,500

per year, all IRAs combined

Age 50+

$6,500

$5,500 base + $1,000 catch-up

Deadline (closed)

15 April 2019

2018 contribution window has passed

Source for the limits: IRS Notice 2017-64, which announced the 2018 cost-of-living adjustments under IRC §415(d). The $5,500 / $6,500 figures had been stable since 2013 because the inflation adjustment rounds to the nearest $500 and inflation between 2013 and 2018 was modest. The catch-up portion is set by statute at $1,000 and was not indexed for inflation until SECURE 2.0 modified it for 2024 and later.

§ II

2018 Roth IRA income phase-outs

Filing statusFull contribution if MAGI belowPhase-out rangeNo contribution above
Single / Head of household$120,000$120K to $135K$135,000
Married filing jointly$189,000$189K to $199K$199,000
Married filing separately$0$0 to $10K$10,000

Source: IRS Notice 2017-64. The MFS phase-out has been $0 to $10,000 since the Roth was created in the Taxpayer Relief Act of 1997 and is not indexed for inflation, which is why it stays a punishingly narrow window.

§ III

The TCJA backdrop: why 2018 was Roth's structural turn

2018 was not just another tax year. The Tax Cuts and Jobs Act, signed 22 December 2017 and effective from 1 January 2018, reset the federal income-tax brackets to the lowest levels in modern history. The 15% bracket became 12%. The 25% bracket became 22%. The 28% bracket became 24%. The 39.6% top rate became 37%. These changes are scheduled to sunset at the end of 2025 unless Congress extends them, which is the central tension in any pre-2026 Roth conversion strategy.

Why did this matter for Roth? Because the Roth vs Traditional choice is, at its core, a question about your tax rate today versus your tax rate later. When today's rate is low, paying tax now (Roth) is cheaper than paying tax later (Traditional). The TCJA, by dropping today's rate, made the Roth question much easier to answer for most filers. A single earner with $60,000 of taxable income in 2017 was in the 25% bracket. The same earner in 2018 was in the 22% bracket. A 3-percentage-point cut on a $5,500 contribution is small in absolute dollars, but over a 30-year horizon it is the difference between a meaningful sacrifice and a small one.

The other 2018 wrinkle was the elimination of Roth conversion recharacterisation. Before TCJA, you could convert a Traditional IRA to a Roth and then change your mind by 15 October of the following year if the market dropped. TCJA closed that door for conversions completed in 2018 and later. Once you convert, you owe the tax. This affects how conversion strategies are sequenced: convert in tranches, not lumps, and convert early in the year so you can monitor before the tax bill lands.

For new contributions, 2018 was straightforward. The limits were $5,500 base and $6,500 with catch-up, identical to 2017. The phase-outs nudged up modestly (single from $118K-$133K to $120K-$135K, MFJ from $186K-$196K to $189K-$199K). The deadline of 15 April 2019 has long passed. If you missed the 2018 contribution, that capacity is gone. The IRS does not allow late prior-year contributions once the filing deadline closes, and there is no grace period for a missed IRA contribution beyond what the 6-month extension Form 4868 permits for the original return.

Historically, 2018 is the year you stop pricing Roth as a luxury and start pricing it as the default. The mental model up to 2017 was "Traditional now, Roth maybe". From 2018 onward, with rates this low for the foreseeable future, the mental model flips to "Roth now, Traditional only if you have a specific reason". That reason is almost always: you are in the 32%, 35%, or 37% bracket today and confidently expect to be in 22% or lower in retirement. Every other filer has a Roth case.

§ IV

What changed from 2017

The 2018 contribution limits did not change from 2017. The$5,500 / $6,500 figures had been stable since 2013. What did change was the policy backdrop around them. Five things worth noting in any 2018 IRA decision review.

  1. Brackets dropped. The new TCJA rate schedule replaced the prior one, lowering most marginal rates by 1 to 4 percentage points. Source: H.R. 1, 115th Congress.
  2. Standard deduction nearly doubled. $12,000 single, $24,000 MFJ for 2018 (up from $6,350 / $12,700 in 2017). This shifted millions of filers into lower effective brackets and made Roth contributions yet more attractive.
  3. Roth conversion recharacterisation eliminated. IRC §408A(d)(6) as amended by TCJA §13611. Once you convert, it sticks. Pre-2018 conversions could be recharacterised by 15 October of the following year; the last eligible recharacterisation deadline was 15 October 2018 for 2017 conversions.
  4. Roth phase-outs nudged up. Single from $118K-$133K to $120K-$135K, MFJ from $186K-$196K to $189K-$199K. Modest, but every $1,000 of phase-out movement is some people getting back into the full Roth window.
  5. Backdoor Roth was implicitly blessed by the conference report. The TCJA conference report (December 2017) explicitly stated that the existing practice of contributing to a non-deductible Traditional IRA and converting to Roth is permitted. This put years of legal uncertainty about "step transaction doctrine" objections to bed. Source: Conference Report 115-466.
§ V

2018 in hindsight: did people use the Roth window?

The Investment Company Institute (ICI) IRA Owners Survey series tracks IRA ownership and contribution behaviour. The 2018 data showed Roth IRAs held by roughly 21% of US households, with Roth contributions running below Traditional contributions despite the rate cut. Most filers did not adjust their Roth-vs-Traditional mix to reflect the TCJA bracket cut. Inertia is the most powerful force in retirement saving.

Conversion volume tells a different story. The IRS Statistics of Income data for tax year 2018 (released 2020) showed Roth conversion activity flat year over year, in spite of the TCJA rate cut making conversions cheaper. The likely explanation: most filers who would have considered a conversion were tracking the elimination of recharacterisation and went smaller, not larger.

The lesson for 2026 readers: a rate cut creates a window, but the window only matters if you act on it. If you have a Traditional IRA today and you believe your retirement rate will be at least equal to your current rate, the math says to convert during low-income years, in tranches that fill the next bracket without spilling over. The same math that applied in 2018 applies in 2026, with one difference: 2026 is closer to the TCJA sunset (originally scheduled for end of 2025), so any rate increase that lands could make the math even more favourable in hindsight.

§ VI

FAQ

What were the 2018 IRA contribution limits?

$5,500 under 50 and $6,500 with the $1,000 catch-up if 50 or older. These limits applied across all of your IRAs combined, Roth and Traditional. The figures came from IRS Notice 2017-64 under IRC §415(d) cost-of-living rules.

Was 2018 the first year of TCJA brackets?

Yes. The Tax Cuts and Jobs Act was signed 22 December 2017 and took effect 1 January 2018. The lower brackets (12%, 22%, 24%, 32%, 35%, 37%) replaced the prior ones (15%, 25%, 28%, 33%, 35%, 39.6%).

Can I recharacterise a 2018 Roth conversion?

No. TCJA eliminated recharacterisation for any conversion completed in 2018 or later. The last eligible recharacterisation deadline was 15 October 2018 for 2017 conversions.

Can I still make a 2018 IRA contribution?

No. The deadline was 15 April 2019 and the IRS does not allow late prior-year contributions once the deadline passes. If you missed it, the capacity is permanently gone.

What was the Roth income phase-out for 2018?

Single and head of household: $120,000 to $135,000 MAGI. Married filing jointly: $189,000 to $199,000. Married filing separately (living with spouse): $0 to $10,000.

Did 2018 have the same backdoor Roth steps as today?

Yes. The mechanics are unchanged: a non-deductible Traditional IRA contribution followed by an immediate conversion to Roth, with Form 8606 filed to track basis. The conference report on TCJA explicitly blessed this practice in late 2017, which removed any lingering legal ambiguity.

Not financial, tax, or legal advice. Figures above are sourced from IRS Notice 2017-64, the Internal Revenue Code, the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act of 2017, and ICI published research. Tax laws change. Your facts and circumstances differ. Consult a fiduciary financial advisor, CPA, or qualified retirement planner before making contributions, conversions, or rollovers. The 2018 tax year is closed and no new contributions for 2018 can be made.